Swap-bot Time: December 24, 2024 10:04 am
www.swap-bot.com

Threes ratings for Lucky12324

Use the controls to the right to show only the ratings you are interested in.

3
rating
 
3
rating
Comment: Hello Kelly, I received your chunky book page for this swap and did like how you used felt for the front page of the chunky book page. I understood that you were doing Australia because of the "down under" reference in your title. However, a couple of things I feel did not meet swap requirements and so I felt a 3 was appropriate. 1. a heavier piece of paper needed to be use as the foundation of the chunky book page 2. on the page there were to be items that related to the country you were featuring. Since you were featuring Australia--there needed to pictures of things that related to Australia(i.e. flag, kangroos, koala bear, map, etc.) Also, words labeling things could be included. On the back of the page general info about the country could be included. I just was not able to see how Nemo was related to Australia. I hope I was clear about why I gave a 3 and not a 5. Barb sleepingrover2010
Response: Quote from actual swap: "Please use heavy cardstock" I used heavy cardstock and felt as well for the background. Nemo is related to Australia because the movie is based in Australia (throughout the entire movie Nemo is lost in Sydney, it's a huge part of the movie), and I also used a famous Australian phrase as well. General info about Australia being put on the back is optional according to the swap description. I'd also like to add that I feel this is an unfair rating because my swap did meet swap requirements and perhaps the problem lies in the swap description because the term "heavy" can be interpreted differently by others. I would also like to add that I NEVER heard from sleepinggrover2010 about her problems with my chunky book page prior to receiving a 3 rating. I also would like to point out that in well over 100 swaps I have never received anything other than a 5 rating because I make sure that my swaps ALWAYS meet the swap requirements as I understand/interpret them.

Rating Overview

Overall Hearts Stars Hosted
4.8980 158 77 100
Completed Fives Threes Ones
304 343 2 8
Type 1 Type 2 Type 3 Uncategorized
3 51 117 133

Show only: